Wintersun's Groundhog's Day Thread

Werecow

Well-Known Member
Joined
Jan 9, 2014
Messages
1,399
Reaction score
1,861
Location
UK
It's had a very messy development. So many staff members have left the project and it's going through so many versions. BioWare need a really strong come back.
I want another Dragon Age Origins so badly. Although i liked Inquisition, it felt like playing an offline MMO. Strangely empty and shallow feeling world in regards to properly written quests, and full of dull filler and fetch quests.
The leaked footage from a couple months back looked like they were trying to be God Of War this time. I wish Bioware would just get back to making RPGs instead of chasing game styles they're not so good at.
 

p0ke

7-string guitard
Joined
Jul 25, 2007
Messages
3,232
Reaction score
2,234
Location
Salo, Finland
wasn't time more-or-less complete 17 years ago?

I guess so, it was originally supposed to be released in 2006 according to wikipedia. So I guess my earlier statement was wrong, Time is more delayed than the power plant :lol: They started building it in 2005 and it was originally supposed to start producing electricity in 2009 (now it is supposedly finished and after a bit more testing production should start in a few months), so it kinda sounds like Jari might have been leading the project all along...
 

Lorcan Ward

7slinger
Joined
May 15, 2009
Messages
6,835
Reaction score
5,059
Location
Ireland
I want another Dragon Age Origins so badly. Although i liked Inquisition, it felt like playing an offline MMO. Strangely empty and shallow feeling world in regards to properly written quests, and full of dull filler and fetch quests.
The leaked footage from a couple months back looked like they were trying to be God Of War this time. I wish Bioware would just get back to making RPGs instead of chasing game styles they're not so good at.

The world needs a Dragon Age game. It's nearly 9 years since the last one and like you said they are going to copy a God of War style hack N slash or Dark Souls/Elden Ring. The MMO style games were a big miss step. I enjoyed latest DA and ME but they were packed full of content in one way but also really empty and unmemorable. They thought Anthem was going to be a huge success and started changing their games to model it. DA 4 would have been a disaster if they had gone the full MMO route.

I guess so, it was originally supposed to be released in 2006 according to wikipedia. So I guess my earlier statement was wrong, Time is more delayed than the power plant :lol: They started building it in 2005 and it was originally supposed to start producing electricity in 2009 (now it is supposedly finished and after a bit more testing production should start in a few months), so it kinda sounds like Jari might have been leading the project all along...

In a realistic album cycle it would have been out 06/07. I'd have to check the old website posts but I recall the earlier ones saying the album was finished and ready to mix around then.
 

Neon_Knight_

Well-Known Member
Joined
Nov 26, 2012
Messages
1,495
Reaction score
1,603
Location
England
What is weird, I've never seen so much interest on a single album to realease, and interest towards musician's personal or his company's finances. I wouldn't even call it "an interest" , because mostly arguments are slandering predictions without basing anything on facts. Because something you obsess about isn't happening yet, doesn't mean it's ever going to happen. Or trying to take some kind of advantage point in a debate, even if you even don't listen to the band. What it even means to you then? It's only your fault and made by your choices filled with pointless bs.

- 2006 Jari states that Time isn't happening yet because of numerous problems in the production and decides to split it in two parts
- 2012 Time I sees the daylight, fans approved the album too, got lot of praises from reviews
- 2014 Jari stops working on Time II, because he doesn't have enough resources to create his 'true vision'
- 2015 - 2017 The Forest Seasons is being written and recorded
- Spring 2017, the crowdfunding is announced to fund release of The Forest Seasons, touring over three continents, and to make future Wintersun albums possible

Fast forward to somewhere around 2022 Jari states that he's working on four different Wintersun albums, one of them being the mighty and highly anticipated Time II, which no one have heard even a glimpse. The naysayers cry about it just as much like in the past 15 or so years.
This is such a misleading summary of events that you must be either Jari, a friend/relative of Jari, or a Wintersun fan in complete denial. Which is it? (This is a completely genuine and reasonable question, considering how rose-tinted and defensive your post is).

The reality, based purely on what Jari has openly stated, not speculation:
- Jari used up all of the studio time provided by the record label he had signed a contract with for Time II. He stated in 2014 that he has stopped working on Time II.
- Later in 2014, Jari started posting about crowdfunding for Time II (not for non-Time II releases). Here's the proof.
- In 2017, he began crowdfunding to build his own studio - repeatedly stating on social media that he was still working on Time II, alongside other new material (inc. The Four Seasons). Although those contributing to the crowdfund copy of 'The Four Seasons' was included, he stated that this studio was "absolutely essential in order to finish TIME II". Here's the proof.
- After repeatedly hinting at Time II being almost complete (I believe he has said "90% complete" a few times, only to then state the same completion % after detailing further progress made), he recently stated that he hasn't worked on Time II since 2014. This is a complete contradiction of numerous comments / statements he has made about Time II progress during the years between 2014-2023 (i.e. he has lied to his fans). Here's the proof:

1680524731448.png

^This was posted by Jari on the Wintersun Facebook page in February 2023. Each time someone directly called him out for contradicting himself (i.e. lying), he stopped replying to that comment and moved on to defending himself against other critical comments instead.


What I will speculate on (with very high confidence) is that Jari has chosen not to release Time II because it would be less financially lucrative than releasing any other material. His former record label would take a huge cut of any revenue generated by Time II, while the revenue from anything released by his crowdfunded studio would be all his to keep. Although a bit amoral to dupe the record label like that (he has a contract after all), I can kind of accept this approach. What I can't accept or tolerate is him actively misleading his own fans, repeatedly and over a period of many years, to dupe them out of their hard-earned money for his own financial benefit.
 
Last edited:

eddyrox

Well-Known Member
Joined
Oct 14, 2011
Messages
63
Reaction score
47
Location
Hollywood, CA
been noting that Temmu is doing a lot of teaching and playing out with his coverband over the last 2 years....:cheers:not that he has anything to do with Jari's writing process....
 

BenSolace

Divine Solace
Joined
Nov 12, 2007
Messages
520
Reaction score
144
Location
England
What I will speculate on (with very high confidence) is that Jari has chosen not to release Time II because it would be less financially lucrative than releasing any other material. His former record label would take a huge cut of any revenue generated by Time II, while the revenue from anything released by his crowdfunded studio would be all his to keep. Although a bit amoral to dupe the record label like that (he has a contract after all), I can kind of accept this approach.
Even in the event that his contract specifically covers the release of Time II and not just "another album," I don't see the advantage in not releasing works that not only is (or maybe it's now "was"?) he outspokenly proud of, but that the fans i.e. the ones that actually enable him to be a full time musician, deservedly or not, really want to hear.

At the moment he is releasing nothing, so surely 30% of something is better than 100% of nothing, and if it's 90% done as he suggests then I don't see how it's not an easy win over starting with other projects from square one, especially given it could earn him back some credibility and respect.

been noting that Temmu is doing a lot of teaching and playing out with his coverband over the last 2 years....:cheers:not that he has anything to do with Jari's writing process....
I can't help but feel a little bad for Teemu, specifically. He's been with the band since he was a teenager IIRC and has progressed so far playing wise (surpassing Jari himself I'd dare to state) that playing covers and teaching seems like such a shame after the heights Wintersun could have gone on to experience.
 

Neon_Knight_

Well-Known Member
Joined
Nov 26, 2012
Messages
1,495
Reaction score
1,603
Location
England
Even in the event that his contract specifically covers the release of Time II and not just "another album," I don't see the advantage in not releasing works that not only is (or maybe it's now "was"?) he outspokenly proud of, but that the fans i.e. the ones that actually enable him to be a full time musician, deservedly or not, really want to hear.
His contract included X amount of studio time for an album, which happened to be Time. Jari decided to split it into two albums after he had already used studio time funded by the label to work on both Time I & Time II - i.e. the label funded that specific material, so has financial rights to revenue from the release of that specific material (but not subsequent material he produces without any input from them). Every hour he invests into Time II is less profitable to him than an hour invested into "another album".

At the moment he is releasing nothing, so surely 30% of something is better than 100% of nothing, and if it's 90% done as he suggests then I don't see how it's not an easy win over starting with other projects from square one, especially given it could earn him back some credibility and respect.
Some days he says "just this one tiny thing is left to finish off", then other days he says he hasn't worked on it since 2014. Simply not constantly contradicting himself (lying to fans) would help his credibility.


This review of the "single" (more like segment of a song awaiting vocals) that took Jari six years to release is pretty on the money. It's nothing that hasn't been done before in past decades with far less processing power and it's really not something that any other band would release as a "single" that they expect fans to pay for.
 

Metropolis

Well-Known Member
Joined
Mar 16, 2010
Messages
2,187
Reaction score
2,248
Location
Vantaa, Finland
been noting that Temmu is doing a lot of teaching and playing out with his coverband over the last 2 years....:cheers:not that he has anything to do with Jari's writing process....

Smackbound is not a cover band, I think you mistake it to Run For Cover where they had same lineup.
 

Neon_Knight_

Well-Known Member
Joined
Nov 26, 2012
Messages
1,495
Reaction score
1,603
Location
England
View attachment 123420

I thought some of these lines were comedy gold. Now I'm convinced he's trolling
I'm sure that, somewhere in this thread, someone joked about the guitar Jari needs to finish Time II not having been invented yet (in response to a ridiculous post by Jari about needing more processing power again). :lol:

As amusing as this post is, it pisses me off that Jari doesn't seem to understand that he has just confessed to spending his fan's money (from crowdfunding) on "specialised custom guitars", to achieve tunings in reality that other people have previously achieved with production baritone guitars.

It's also frustrating that he seems to think it's a positive that 'Warning' is unrelated to any of the multiple albums he supposedly has in the works. Yet another delay to the fans getting something they actually want and paid for (via crowdfunding).
 

NoodleFace

Delicious Noodles
Joined
Jul 20, 2007
Messages
1,990
Reaction score
2,940
Location
Somerset, MA
I'm sure that, somewhere in this thread, someone joked about the guitar Jari needs to finish Time II not having been invented yet (in response to a ridiculous post by Jari about needing more processing power again). :lol:

As amusing as this post is, it pisses me off that Jari doesn't seem to understand that he has just confessed to spending his fan's money (from crowdfunding) on "specialised custom guitars", to achieve tunings in reality that other people have previously achieved with production baritone guitars.

It's also frustrating that he seems to think it's a positive that 'Warning' is unrelated to any of the multiple albums he supposedly has in the works. Yet another delay to the fans getting something they actually want and paid for (via crowdfunding).
Yeah I caught onto the undertones of that too, he just blew a bunch of money on custom guitars. Not a bad life
 

nightflameauto

Well-Known Member
Joined
Sep 25, 2010
Messages
2,601
Reaction score
3,261
Location
Sioux Falls, SD
Cannibal Corpse literally has videos on Youtube of them in the studio taking production floyds, redrilling them and/or the guitars to give them more adjustment for intonation so they can tune lower just to get the job done. Jari needs specialized guitars for tunings every Tom, Dick, and Sally use every day on everything from Gibson scale to 30" baritones? WTF?

This guy would be comedy gold if not for taking money from fans.
 

p0ke

7-string guitard
Joined
Jul 25, 2007
Messages
3,232
Reaction score
2,234
Location
Salo, Finland
No market for low tunings? Is he being serious :lol:

Oh well, at least he's saying he now has the capability to do something instead of coming up with more excuses... I still don't expect him/them to release anything anytime soon.
 

SalsaWood

I like metal.
Contributor
Joined
May 15, 2017
Messages
394
Reaction score
693
Location
NoVA
So the dude doesn't even play 7 strings and he's crying about production guitars not having the options he "needs".

Cry me a river and drown in it.
 
Top